Genesee County Road Commission DATE: 03/27/2007 TABULATION OF Bids - DETAILS PAGE: 1 __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CONTRACT ID: 67-W356 Alt A PROJECT(S): GCRC 67-W356 CONTRACT DESCRIPTION: Williamsburg Farms and Williamsburg Farms No. 2, 3 & 4 __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ VENDOR RANKING: ================================================================================================================================== TOTAL % OVER % OVER RANK BIDDER BID LOW BID EST ================================================================================================================================== 0 ENGINEER'S ESTIMATE $ 1,634,314.50 24.8323% 0% 1 Ace Asphalt & Paving Company $ 1,309,208.49 0.0000% -19.8925% 2 C & D Hughes, Inc. $ 1,326,648.70 1.3321% -18.8254% 3 Cadillac Asphalt LLC $ 1,402,421.60 7.1198% -14.1890% 4 Zito Construction Co. $ 1,410,127.70 7.7084% -13.7175% 5 San Marino Excavating, Inc. $ 1,614,242.45 23.2991% -1.2282% __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ |(0) |(1) |(2) | |ENGINEER'S ESTIMATE |Ace Asphalt & Paving Company|C & D Hughes, Inc. | LINE / ITEM CODE QTY UNIT| | | | ITEM DESCRIPTION | UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 0001 2030011 18.000 Ea | 250.00 4500.00| 300.000 5400.00| 400.000 7200.00| Dr Structure, Rem | | | | 0002 2040006 6625.000 Ft | 6.50 43062.50| 5.000 33125.00| 8.000 53000.00| Curb and Gutter, Rem | | | | 0003 2047011 33736.000 Syd | 6.00 202416.00| 1.500 50604.00| 3.000 101208.00| Pavt, Rem, Modified | | | | 0004 2050010 100.000 Cyd | 6.00 600.00| 4.000 400.00| 7.000 700.00| Embankment, CIP | | | | 0005 2050016 5910.000 Cyd | 5.50 32505.00| 10.000 59100.00| 2.000 11820.00| Excavation, Earth | | | | 0006 2057021 150.000 Cyd | 32.00 4800.00| 32.000 4800.00| 15.000 2250.00| Subgrade Undercutting, Type II, Modified | | | | 0007 2080006 73.000 Ea | 50.00 3650.00| 45.000 3285.00| 100.000 7300.00| Erosion Control, Inlet Protection, Fabric| | | | 0008 2080025 225.000 Ft | 2.00 450.00| 2.000 450.00| 1.500 337.50| Erosion Control, Silt Fence | | | | 0009 3027011 2250.000 Syd | 5.00 11250.00| 3.000 6750.00| 4.000 9000.00| Aggregate Base, 3 inch, 21AA, Modified | | | | 0010 3030026 600.000 Syd | 1.50 900.00| 2.000 1200.00| 3.000 1800.00| Geotextile, Stabilization | | | | 0011 3067031 500.000 Ton | 20.00 10000.00| 14.000 7000.00| 25.000 12500.00| Maintenance Gravel, Special | | | | 0012 4020866 100.000 Ft | 35.00 3500.00| 42.000 4200.00| 40.000 4000.00| Sewer, Cl III, 12 inch, Tr Det B | | | | 0013 4021204 2.000 Ea | 279.00 558.00| 250.000 500.00| 400.000 800.00| Sewer Tap, 12 inch | | | | 0014 4030005 25.000 Ea | 1300.00 32500.00| 1100.000 27500.00| 1200.000 30000.00| Dr Structure, 48 inch dia | | | | 0015 4030051 13360.000 Lb | 1.50 20040.00| 1.000 13360.00| 1.500 20040.00| Dr Structure Cover | | | | 0016 4030064 4.000 Ea | 130.00 520.00| 100.000 400.00| 400.000 1600.00| Dr Structure, Tap, 12 inch | | | | 0017 4037050 3.000 Ea | 750.00 2250.00| 350.000 1050.00| 400.000 1200.00| Adjusting Sanitary Sewer Manhole Cover, S| | | | 0018 4037050 11.000 Ea | 750.00 8250.00| 600.000 6600.00| 800.000 8800.00| Drainage Structure, Reconstruct, Case 1, | | | | 0019 4040061 19500.000 Ft | 4.00 78000.00| 4.500 87750.00| 4.000 78000.00| Underdrain, Subbase, 4 inch | | | | 0020 4040071 387.000 Ft | 5.00 1935.00| 7.000 2709.00| 4.000 1548.00| Underdrain, Subgrade, 4 inch | | | | 0021 4047001 60.000 Ft | 10.00 600.00| 10.000 600.00| 15.000 900.00| House Drain, 4 inch | | | | 0022 4047001 50.000 Ft | 12.00 600.00| 12.000 600.00| 15.000 750.00| House Drain, 6 inch | | | | 0023 5020003 380.000 Syd | 2.00 760.00| 5.000 1900.00| 3.000 1140.00| Cold Milling HMA Surface | | | | 0024 5027011 48.000 Syd | 40.00 1920.00| 50.000 2400.00| 51.000 2448.00| HMA Residential Approach, Special | | | | 0025 8017011 3604.000 Syd | 32.00 115328.00| 27.560 99326.24| 26.000 93704.00| Driveway, Nonreinf Conc, 5 inch | | | | 0026 8020031 4300.000 Ft | 15.00 64500.00| 14.980 64414.00| 13.800 59340.00| Curb and Gutter, Conc, Det D2 | | | | 0027 8070095 100.000 Ea | 50.00 5000.00| 40.000 4000.00| 50.000 5000.00| Post, Mailbox | | | | 0028 8120025 25.000 Ton | 150.00 3750.00| 300.000 7500.00| 200.000 5000.00| Dust Palliative, Applied | | | | 0029 8127051 1.000 LS | 20000.00 20000.00| 15000.000 15000.00| 20000.000 20000.00| Maintaining Traffic, Max. $20,000 | | | | 0030 8507001 2330.000 Ft | 16.00 37280.00| 14.950 34833.50| 13.800 32154.00| Curb and Gutter, Conc, Det D2, Modified | | | | 0031 8507011 30693.000 Syd | 30.00 920790.00| 24.750 759651.75| 24.400 748909.20| Pavement, Special | | | | 0032 8507011 700.000 Syd | 3.00 2100.00| 4.000 2800.00| 6.000 4200.00| Project Cleanup and Restoration, Special | | | | __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CONTRACT TOTALS | $1,634,314.50| $1,309,208.49| $1,326,648.70| __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ |(3) |(4) |(5) | |Cadillac Asphalt LLC |Zito Construction Co. |San Marino Excavating, Inc. | LINE / ITEM CODE QTY UNIT| | | | ITEM DESCRIPTION | UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 0001 2030011 18.000 Ea | 300.000 5400.00| 475.000 8550.00| 600.000 10800.00| Dr Structure, Rem | | | | 0002 2040006 6625.000 Ft | 5.000 33125.00| 8.000 53000.00| 5.250 34781.25| Curb and Gutter, Rem | | | | 0003 2047011 33736.000 Syd | 3.000 101208.00| 3.700 124823.20| 4.050 136630.80| Pavt, Rem, Modified | | | | 0004 2050010 100.000 Cyd | 4.000 400.00| 20.000 2000.00| 9.250 925.00| Embankment, CIP | | | | 0005 2050016 5910.000 Cyd | 10.000 59100.00| 10.000 59100.00| 32.750 193552.50| Excavation, Earth | | | | 0006 2057021 150.000 Cyd | 32.000 4800.00| 33.000 4950.00| 26.500 3975.00| Subgrade Undercutting, Type II, Modified | | | | 0007 2080006 73.000 Ea | 45.000 3285.00| 75.000 5475.00| 21.000 1533.00| Erosion Control, Inlet Protection, Fabric| | | | 0008 2080025 225.000 Ft | 2.000 450.00| 3.000 675.00| 1.100 247.50| Erosion Control, Silt Fence | | | | 0009 3027011 2250.000 Syd | 3.000 6750.00| 3.800 8550.00| 3.400 7650.00| Aggregate Base, 3 inch, 21AA, Modified | | | | 0010 3030026 600.000 Syd | 2.000 1200.00| 3.000 1800.00| 2.800 1680.00| Geotextile, Stabilization | | | | 0011 3067031 500.000 Ton | 14.000 7000.00| 22.000 11000.00| 15.000 7500.00| Maintenance Gravel, Special | | | | 0012 4020866 100.000 Ft | 42.000 4200.00| 46.000 4600.00| 54.000 5400.00| Sewer, Cl III, 12 inch, Tr Det B | | | | 0013 4021204 2.000 Ea | 250.000 500.00| 200.000 400.00| 550.000 1100.00| Sewer Tap, 12 inch | | | | 0014 4030005 25.000 Ea | 1100.000 27500.00| 1300.000 32500.00| 1900.000 47500.00| Dr Structure, 48 inch dia | | | | 0015 4030051 13360.000 Lb | 1.000 13360.00| 1.000 13360.00| 1.050 14028.00| Dr Structure Cover | | | | 0016 4030064 4.000 Ea | 100.000 400.00| 200.000 800.00| 425.000 1700.00| Dr Structure, Tap, 12 inch | | | | 0017 4037050 3.000 Ea | 350.000 1050.00| 655.000 1965.00| 440.000 1320.00| Adjusting Sanitary Sewer Manhole Cover, S| | | | 0018 4037050 11.000 Ea | 600.000 6600.00| 480.000 5280.00| 440.000 4840.00| Drainage Structure, Reconstruct, Case 1, | | | | 0019 4040061 19500.000 Ft | 4.500 87750.00| 4.500 87750.00| 5.000 97500.00| Underdrain, Subbase, 4 inch | | | | 0020 4040071 387.000 Ft | 7.000 2709.00| 5.000 1935.00| 7.500 2902.50| Underdrain, Subgrade, 4 inch | | | | 0021 4047001 60.000 Ft | 10.000 600.00| 12.000 720.00| 11.000 660.00| House Drain, 4 inch | | | | 0022 4047001 50.000 Ft | 12.000 600.00| 12.000 600.00| 15.000 750.00| House Drain, 6 inch | | | | 0023 5020003 380.000 Syd | 18.000 6840.00| 6.000 2280.00| 13.750 5225.00| Cold Milling HMA Surface | | | | 0024 5027011 48.000 Syd | 37.000 1776.00| 50.000 2400.00| 40.000 1920.00| HMA Residential Approach, Special | | | | 0025 8017011 3604.000 Syd | 28.000 100912.00| 30.000 108120.00| 25.950 93523.80| Driveway, Nonreinf Conc, 5 inch | | | | 0026 8020031 4300.000 Ft | 15.000 64500.00| 13.200 56760.00| 14.450 62135.00| Curb and Gutter, Conc, Det D2 | | | | 0027 8070095 100.000 Ea | 40.000 4000.00| 48.000 4800.00| 65.000 6500.00| Post, Mailbox | | | | 0028 8120025 25.000 Ton | 100.000 2500.00| 200.000 5000.00| 220.000 5500.00| Dust Palliative, Applied | | | | 0029 8127051 1.000 LS | 12000.000 12000.00| 14000.000 14000.00| 12000.000 12000.00| Maintaining Traffic, Max. $20,000 | | | | 0030 8507001 2330.000 Ft | 15.000 34950.00| 13.200 30756.00| 14.420 33598.60| Curb and Gutter, Conc, Det D2, Modified | | | | 0031 8507011 30693.000 Syd | 26.200 804156.60| 24.500 751978.50| 26.500 813364.50| Pavement, Special | | | | 0032 8507011 700.000 Syd | 4.000 2800.00| 6.000 4200.00| 5.000 3500.00| Project Cleanup and Restoration, Special | | | | __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CONTRACT TOTALS | $1,402,421.60| $1,410,127.70| $1,614,242.45| __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________