DATE: 07/24/2007 TABULATION OF Bids - DETAILS PAGE: 1 __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CONTRACT ID: 2007 P2 PROJECT(S): 175-W214, 96-W856 CONTRACT DESCRIPTION: Road Repairs __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ VENDOR RANKING: ================================================================================================================================== TOTAL % OVER % OVER RANK BIDDER BID LOW BID EST ================================================================================================================================== 0 ENGINEER'S ESTIMATE $ 188,600.00 -2.8148% 0% 1 Ace Asphalt & Paving Company $ 194,062.50 0.0000% 2.8963% 2 Pro-Line Asphalt Paving Corp. $ 241,196.38 24.2880% 27.8878% 3 Cadillac Asphalt LLC $ 298,942.50 54.0444% 58.5061% __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ PROJECT # 175-W214 |(0) |(1) |(2) | |ENGINEER'S ESTIMATE |Ace Asphalt & Paving Company|Pro-Line Asphalt Paving Corp| LINE / ITEM CODE QTY UNIT| | | | ITEM DESCRIPTION | UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ 0001 2047011 1000.000 Syd | 5.00 5000.00| 3.500 3500.00| 13.220 13220.00| Pavt, Rem, Modified | | | | 0002 2057021 200.000 Cyd | 30.00 6000.00| 40.000 8000.00| 30.420 6084.00| Subgrade Undercutting, Type II, Modified | | | | 0003 2090001 0.500 LS | 1500.00 750.00| 1000.000 500.00| 1155.860 577.93| Project Cleanup | | | | 0004 3027031 400.000 Ton | 22.00 8800.00| 18.000 7200.00| 25.230 10092.00| Aggregate Base, Modified | | | | 0005 3030020 1000.000 Syd | 2.50 2500.00| 2.000 2000.00| 2.830 2830.00| Geotextile Separator | | | | 0006 3077031 50.000 Ton | 30.00 1500.00| 21.000 1050.00| 40.140 2007.00| Shoulder, Class II, Modified | | | | 0007 4040061 1000.000 Ft | 10.00 10000.00| 2.000 2000.00| 20.400 20400.00| Underdrain, Subbase, 4 inch | | | | 0008 5020034 300.000 Ton | 60.00 18000.00| 70.750 21225.00| 64.230 19269.00| HMA, 13A | | | | 0009 8507031 100.000 Ton | 65.00 6500.00| 70.750 7075.00| 78.590 7859.00| Machine Patching | | | | 0010 8507031 5.000 Ton | 65.00 325.00| 250.000 1250.00| 98.130 490.65| Spot Patching | | | | 0011 8507051 0.500 LS | 1500.00 750.00| 7375.000 3687.50| 4623.440 2311.72| Maintaining Traffic, Special | | | | PROJECT TOTALS | $60,125.00| $57,487.50| $85,141.30| __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ PROJECT # 96-W856 0012 2047011 3810.000 Syd | 5.00 19050.00| 2.500 9525.00| 7.030 26784.30| Pavt, Rem, Modified | | | | 0013 2057021 100.000 Cyd | 30.00 3000.00| 40.000 4000.00| 30.420 3042.00| Subgrade Undercutting, Type II, Modified | | | | 0014 2090001 0.500 LS | 1500.00 750.00| 1000.000 500.00| 1155.860 577.93| Project Cleanup | | | | 0015 3027031 1500.000 Ton | 22.00 33000.00| 18.000 27000.00| 21.080 31620.00| Aggregate Base, Modified | | | | 0016 3030020 2500.000 Syd | 2.50 6250.00| 2.000 5000.00| 2.830 7075.00| Geotextile Separator | | | | 0017 3077031 50.000 Ton | 30.00 1500.00| 21.000 1050.00| 45.770 2288.50| Shoulder, Class II, Modified | | | | 0018 5020034 1200.000 Ton | 50.50 60600.00| 67.500 81000.00| 64.230 77076.00| HMA, 13A | | | | 0019 8507031 50.000 Ton | 65.00 3250.00| 67.500 3375.00| 75.640 3782.00| Machine Patching | | | | 0020 8507031 5.000 Ton | 65.00 325.00| 250.000 1250.00| 183.940 919.70| Spot Patching | | | | 0021 8507051 0.500 LS | 1500.00 750.00| 7750.000 3875.00| 5779.290 2889.65| Maintaining Traffic, Special | | | | __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ PROJECT TOTALS | $128,475.00| $136,575.00| $156,055.08| __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CONTRACT TOTALS | $188,600.00| $194,062.50| $241,196.38| __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ PROJECT # 96-W856 |(3) | | | |Cadillac Asphalt LLC | | | LINE / ITEM CODE QTY UNIT| | | | ITEM DESCRIPTION | UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| UNIT PRICE AMOUNT| __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ PROJECT TOTALS | $205,232.50| | | __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ PROJECT # 175-W214 0001 2047011 1000.000 Syd | 12.000 12000.00| | | Pavt, Rem, Modified | | | | 0002 2057021 200.000 Cyd | 44.000 8800.00| | | Subgrade Undercutting, Type II, Modified | | | | 0003 2090001 0.500 LS | 12000.000 6000.00| | | Project Cleanup | | | | 0004 3027031 400.000 Ton | 27.000 10800.00| | | Aggregate Base, Modified | | | | 0005 3030020 1000.000 Syd | 1.700 1700.00| | | Geotextile Separator | | | | 0006 3077031 50.000 Ton | 30.000 1500.00| | | Shoulder, Class II, Modified | | | | 0007 4040061 1000.000 Ft | 6.000 6000.00| | | Underdrain, Subbase, 4 inch | | | | 0008 5020034 300.000 Ton | 111.000 33300.00| | | HMA, 13A | | | | 0009 8507031 100.000 Ton | 82.000 8200.00| | | Machine Patching | | | | 0010 8507031 5.000 Ton | 82.000 410.00| | | Spot Patching | | | | 0011 8507051 0.500 LS | 10000.000 5000.00| | | Maintaining Traffic, Special | | | | PROJECT TOTALS | $93,710.00| | | __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ PROJECT # 96-W856 0012 2047011 3810.000 Syd | 12.250 46672.50| | | Pavt, Rem, Modified | | | | 0013 2057021 100.000 Cyd | 44.000 4400.00| | | Subgrade Undercutting, Type II, Modified | | | | 0014 2090001 0.500 LS | 6000.000 3000.00| | | Project Cleanup | | | | 0015 3027031 1500.000 Ton | 27.000 40500.00| | | Aggregate Base, Modified | | | | 0016 3030020 2500.000 Syd | 1.700 4250.00| | | Geotextile Separator | | | | 0017 3077031 50.000 Ton | 30.000 1500.00| | | Shoulder, Class II, Modified | | | | 0018 5020034 1200.000 Ton | 82.000 98400.00| | | HMA, 13A | | | | 0019 8507031 50.000 Ton | 82.000 4100.00| | | Machine Patching | | | | 0020 8507031 5.000 Ton | 82.000 410.00| | | Spot Patching | | | | 0021 8507051 0.500 LS | 4000.000 2000.00| | | Maintaining Traffic, Special | | | | __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ PROJECT TOTALS | $205,232.50| | | __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________ CONTRACT TOTALS | $298,942.50| | | __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________